Sweetie Pies - Fish Creek

I expected the best cake of my life, and it was overwhelming. I would say the torte was worse than average, the crust was very thin and soggy. the filling tasted but really like real cherry!

As our boys frolicked in the hotel pool, we decided to take a quick stroll around the neighborhood, just to pass the time. We were immediately drawn to a cute sign with a couple of ladies drinking wine and eating pies just outside of Sweetie Pie's. The aroma exiting this small building was mesmerizing and bees to honey, we were drawn to the back door. The selection was fairly extensive, so we were forced to choose ONLY 3 Cutie-pies which are personal-sized pies for 1-2 gluttons like us. We chose Raspberry-Cherry, Apple-Cinnamon-Walnuts and Blueberry. Immediately devouring the Raspberry-Cherry, we wondered if we should offer the other two to our 3 teens or give in to our selfish desires and eat the other two sneakily I mean, they didn't even have to know, right? We did eventually yield the other two to them, but not without thoughts of returning someday for a few more pies. Definitely worth the visit.

We saw that they were rated high and decided to check them out. First thing was their covid protocols and political statements on the board outside. Pie slices were $6 a slice. You were only allowed to order outside after ringing a doorbell. The cherry pie I had was more on the dry side. The strawberry rhubarb that my wife had.. well the rhubarb was larger than the strawberries. The crust was good though.

Hey, everybody just wanted to share with my experience on cherry cake shops. all stores have cherry cake for $14.99 to 16.99 for a whole cake. their cakes sell for $25.00 warning unfortunately sweetie pies sell for $7 to $10 dollars more than any other for a torte in all door county. just a fairer head up. be not fooling.

Sweeties pies is a great local shop! I was a little disappointed I couldn’t see the inside of the shop. Not sure because of COVID or lack of space. We got the berried treasure and cherry crumble pie. Whole pies are around $17-20, slices are $6, and mini pies are $10. Would visit again.