Andrea's 25 of Commack

Always excellent!! Their menu options are unique compared to other traditional Italian restaurants. While they have some common dishes, they also offer a variety of creative and delicious options. It's a shame they are closing on 1/17. My husband and I are grateful we were able to dine there one last time before they shut down for good.

The food, service ambiance has always been consistent, Great! Last night, I ordered the shrimp Luciano,husband had the linguini with clams, others had shrimp dinners which were all outstanding! Would highly recommend Andreas 25, one of the finest on Long Island

Food was amazing and the staff was great and very accommodating. You are treated like family there. Highly recommend!

This was one of the worst dining experiences we have ever had. The noise level was nearly intolerable. We would have left as soon as we arrived, but we didn't want to be charged a $50 fee for canceling our reservation within 24 hours, even though we had only made the reservation a few minutes before arriving. We will not be returning or recommending this restaurant. Apologies. I hope this feedback helps the owners improve their food quality and atmosphere.

I celebrated my birthday at this restaurant and had a fantastic experience with both the service and the food.